Mastering the Art of Video Game Critique: Emotion, Bias, and Beyond
Or
How to Complain About Games Online
In today's digital landscape, video games have far surpassed their status as mere entertainment, morphing into a thriving industry and an essential aspect of popular culture. It makes more money than movies and music combined. The critiques of these games, consequently, carry significant weight. They inform purchase decisions, affect perceptions, and even steer the course of future game development. Some games live and die by their aggregate scores. From critics, to players, there are a lot of opinions floating around, but to genuinely influence this industry, it's critical that we traverse beyond our inherent biases and raw emotional responses. If you want to be heard, you need to sound like you know what you are talking about.
Gaming can be a very emotional experience. Whether it's the exhilaration of vanquishing a strong boss, the frustration of a challenging puzzle, or being moved to tears by a heartfelt moment, these experiences bleed into our opinions. The emotions we feel can taint our ideas and opinions for better and worse. This is why developers listen to data more than they do players. If you say one thing, but play in a different way, they will see this and question why this opinion is being voiced.
They want to hear from us. They want the feedback and the advice, but they want this information to make sense. To critique responsibly, it's vital to separate our visceral emotional reactions from our objective analysis. Dev’s want you to feel things when you play, but they also want responsible feedback.
A balanced critique incorporates the critic's understanding of the game's intended audience, the game's creative intent, and an appreciation of the game's genre. It's about respecting the vision and philosophy of the game, even when certain elements aren't necessarily to one's personal taste. This doesn't mean we need to suppress our emotions; but we should ensure they don't cloud our objective assessment.The emotions are why we sit down to write our ideas out in the first place, but they can also taint our ideas.
Every video game is a testament to a complex web of intricate processes, from meticulous story crafting and detailed character designing to immersive world-building and efficient programming. Add to that the constraints of deadlines, budgets, and technical challenges, and we begin to glimpse the countless compromises that game development involves. Voicing our opinions about these things is important because it can show publishers, and developers that we don’t want to compromise and that waiting can be worth it if it means a better product down the road. But our voice is ignored when we fail to make our points in a way that seems analytical and thought out.
For critics, understanding the game creation process should be crucial. It provides context to their critiques, empowering them to offer nuanced, constructive feedback that can contribute meaningfully to future game development. Critics who incorporate this awareness into their reviews move the dialogue beyond simple opinion sharing, fostering a more substantial discussion around game design. Developers can understand the message better when its presented in such a manner.
Critics are in a unique position to bridge the gap between developers and players. They can convert unstructured player feedback into actionable insights for developers and shed light on the intricate process of game development for players. This nurturing of understanding can foster a mutual respect within the gaming community. It can help make developers and gamers happy at the same time.
Moreover, critics have a role in promoting innovation in the industry. By recognizing and commending creative risks in game design and narrative, critics can inspire developers to stretch their creative muscles. On the other hand, offering insightful critique on repetitive content can stimulate developers to break from the conventional, thus facilitating growth and evolution in the industry.
At its heart, being a video game critic goes beyond simply expressing opinions; it requires a balance of objective assessment and understanding. It's about grasping the nuances of game development, encouraging constructive dialogue between developers and players, fostering innovation, and providing balanced reviews. By cultivating these elements in our critiques, we can contribute positively to a more informed and respectful gaming community and, in turn, help shape the future of this dynamic industry.